Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Theory of Objects

 

(Some helpful definitions to aid in understanding Meinong's Theory. )

Existence: 

Being in space and time. Can interact with the physical world.


Subsistence: 

Being without space and time. Abstract, logical, and true, but not physical. Example: numbers, relations.


Absistence: 

Being outside existence and subsistence. Objects that can be thought about and have properties, but neither exist nor subsist. Example: the golden mountain, the round square.

+++++++++

MEINONG - TLDR

Philosopher: Alexius Meinong (1853-1920), Austrian. Student of Franz Brentano.

Main work: Theory of Objects / Gegenstandstheorie (1904)


Core idea: You can think about things that do not exist. For thought to work, every thought must be about SOMETHING. That something must have some kind of being, even if it does not exist in the real world.


He splits being into 3 levels:


1. EXISTENCE (Existenz)

What it is: Things that are in space and time and can interact with the world.

Examples: A chair, a dog, your TV, a rock.

Origin: Normal, everyday objects. This is what most people mean by "real."


2. SUBSISTENCE (Bestand)

What it is: Things that do not exist in space and time, but are still real and true. They do not exist, they subsist.

Examples: Numbers (7), relations (taller than), states of affairs (that it is raining), propositions.

Origin: Meinong needed a place for abstract and logical objects. They are not physical, but math and logic would fall apart without them.


3. ABSISTENCE (Aussersein - literally "being outside")

What it is: Things that neither exist nor subsist, but can still be thought about and have properties. They are "outside being."

Examples: The golden mountain, the round square, the unicorn, the present King of France.

Origin: Meinong's solution to non-existent objects. We can say "the round square is round" and it is true, even though a round square can never exist. It must have some kind of being to have that property.


One-liner to remember:

Existence = it is here.

Subsistence = it is true, but not here.

Absistence = it is not here and cannot be here, but you can still think about it.


Why it matters:

This creates "Meinong's Jungle" - a huge ontology full of non-existent objects. Bertrand Russell attacked it and said we do not need the jungle, we can just fix the language instead. That fight shaped 20th century philosophy of language.

No comments:

Post a Comment